Vital Football

Latest Peterborough United News

A Defensive Midfielder Dilemma!

A Defensive Midfielder Dilemma!

<div style='background-color: #005abb;'><a href='' title='news'>headlines</a></div>

Vital View - Coventry City 1-0 Posh - A Defensive Midfielder Dilemma!

Coventry City 1 -Vs- 0 Peterborough United
Venue: Ricoh Arena
Date: Saturday, 8th April, 2017
Attendance: 10,551 (849 Posh fans)

Posh were looking to make it three wins on the bounce and five games unbeaten but the players looked like they were on a wind down towards the end of the season.

With Posh Chairman Darragh MacAnthony [pictured below] looking on from the stands and with a planned meeting with Posh boss Grant McCann this coming week to discuss who should stay or who should be put on the transfer list, not many players looked like they want to stay!!

Posh had the perfect chance to take the lead in this match when Martin Sameulsen was upended in the box. Surprisingly, Craig Mackail-Smith, not the best penalty taker in his time at Posh, stepped up to blast the kick down the middle of the goal. Unfortunately, the ball hit the keepers legs!

Many people are questioning why Michael Bostwick didn`t take it after Marcus Maddison had missed the previous penalty but he would`ve blasted the ball down the middle as well!! Despite missing his last penalty, surely Maddison has proved the most successful penalty taker in recent times?!?

That penalty miss proved crucial as the midfield diamond failed massively once again allowing a side at the bottom of League One so much room in midfield for which they eventually took advantage early in the second half to score the only goal of the game.

What we can`t understand is in games where we need to take the game to a struggling side do we insist in playing with a defensive midfielder?

When Posh were forced to switch Michael Bostwick from the base of the diamond to central defence and bring Chris Forrester into that position earlier in the season, Posh thrived. Forrester may not have been at his best since the game against Chelsea in January but he is still the most influential player we have for that position.

Anthony Grant was brought in to the club in January and for the first few games was very good in that defensive midfield position at the base of the diamond. He is certainly an improvement on Bostwick in that position but when we need to be more creative and don`t need to be as defensively minded then we surely need Forrester in that position?

When playing against top sides where we need to be strong in midfield then surely that is the time to use a defensive midfielder? Matches against the sides struggling near the bottom of the League are games where we need to be on the front foot and take the game to the opposition. We don`t do that when we employ a defensive midfielder. Admittedly Grant is better going forward than Bostwick but he`s not better than Forrester hence why the latter should play when we need to attack the opposition.

Martin Samuelsen has been poor during his stay at the ABAX Stadium this season but is that simply down to the diamond midfield? He showed his true talent last weekend when Posh reverted back to a 4-4-2 formation so why pick him for the Coventry match only to revert back to a diamond?

That was a massive mistake by Grant McCann and it is hard to fathom why he chose to play a diamond again with Samuelsen in it!

We all know MacAnthony won`t get rid of McCann in the foreseeable future but McCann surely needs to learn quicker than he is. Hopefully when an "experienced" number two arrives during the summer will McCann also improve further and make better decisions.

Don`t forget to vote in the following polls that are running at the time of print:

Coventry City v Posh

Man of the Match
Rate The Ref - Gavin Ward

Posh v Charlton Athletic

Rate The Ref - Graham Salisbury
Man of the Match

This site is looking for bloggers and article contributions, so if you're a fan that can offer us a genuine opinion we would love to share it with the masses!

To email your own unique article/blog for publishing


Photos courtesy of

Follow Vital Peterborough on: facebook and twitter

Join The Vital Debate

Join Vital Peterborough United!

With news and views, polls and article comments, everything you need in a fans site is right here!

Vital Posh is 100% interactive. Not only can you have your say on the articles but you can also suggest an article or a poll so you can air your views.

So why not join Vital Posh today?
It's easy to REGISTER HERE. Simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!.

Get involved
This website is your website and we are looking for people to help run the site. Do you go to most of the games and have an opinion? Why not write a match report? Perhaps you are a budding journalist or even just someone who is very opinionated? Well why not join our team? If this interests you please contact Vital Posh at or
via twitter @VitalPosh.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Monday April 10 2017
Time: 12:30PM

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent Peterborough United Articles

Trotters v Posh - Your Score Predictions

Voting has closed to predict the Bolton Wanderers v Peterborough United Sky Bet EFL League One match. Find out what was voted for and what the favourite prediction was

Team Line-Ups: Bolton Wanderers v Posh

Find out the line-ups for the Sky Bet EFL League One match between Bolton Wanderers and Peterborough United

Trotters Odds-On Favourites to Beat Posh

Football League sponsors Sky Bet have installed Bolton Wanderers as clear favourites to beat their visitors Peterborough United in today`s League One clash

McCann`s Viewpoint: Pre-Bolton Wanderers

Peterborough United boss Grant McCann looks ahead to the final clash of the Sky Bet League One season at Bolton Wanderers and reflects on the season

Archived Vital Posh Articles

Vital Posh articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

How many of the final 10 games will Posh win?
Suggested By:

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Sheff Utd 45 29 10 6 97 44
2 Bolton 45 24 11 10 83 29
3 Fleetwood 45 23 12 10 81 21
4 Scunthorpe 45 23 10 12 79 24
5 Bradford 45 20 18 7 78 19
6 Millwall 45 19 13 13 70 8
7 Southend 45 19 12 14 69 16
8 Rochdale 45 19 11 15 68 9
9 Oxford 45 19 9 17 66 11
10 Bristol Rovers 45 18 12 15 66 -1
11 Peterborough 45 17 11 17 62 3
12 MK Dons 45 15 13 17 58 -1
13 Walsall 45 14 16 15 58 -4
14 Charlton 45 13 18 14 57 4
15 Wimbledon 45 13 17 15 56 -3
16 Northampton 45 14 10 21 52 -13
17 Oldham 45 12 16 17 52 -13
18 Shrewsbury 45 13 12 20 51 -15
19 Bury 45 13 11 21 50 -11
20 Gillingham 45 12 13 20 49 -20
21 Port Vale 45 12 12 21 48 -25
R Swindon 45 11 11 23 44 -19
R Coventry 45 9 12 24 39 -29
R Chesterfield 45 9 10 26 37 -34
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Peterborough United Results (view all)

Peterborough United Fixtures (view all)

Apr 30 2017 12:00PM : Bolton Wanderers (a)
Sky Bet League One
The Vital Football Members League